Getting Started
First gigs, first jokes, first everything
Become a member to post in Banter
Tough Crowd is a members-only community. Your first 24 hours are free — cancel anytime.
Become a memberWhen you get your first ten-minute spot, do you build one ten or join two fives?
I’m getting close to having enough material for a ten, but I can’t decide whether the useful next step is making one set that actually has a shape, or just putting two reliable shorter chunks next to each other and learning what happens. Joining two fives feels safer, but I’m worried I’ll end up with a very obvious reset in the middle. Did you start thinking about transitions and an overall arc as soon as spots got longer, or only once the individual bits were solid enough to survive without constant editing?
How many gigs in do you stop changing your opening line just because you're nervous?
I keep seeing newer comics treat the first line like it has to solve the whole room: introduce you, prove you're funny, explain the premise and calm your nerves before anyone has even settled. Is it better to keep one simple opener for a while so you can actually learn how to deliver it, or keep testing different openings until one feels natural? I'm suspicious that constant rewriting can sometimes be nerves wearing a little writer's hat.
When you start getting longer spots, do you still time every bit separately?
I’ve started timing bits on their own as well as the full set, mostly because “this is about three minutes” turns out to be a wildly optimistic unit of measurement once there are actual laughs and pauses. If you’re moving from fives towards tens, do you keep a rough time for each chunk so you know what can be cut, or does that make the set feel too engineered? I want enough control to lose two minutes cleanly without staring at my notes like I’m doing emergency surgery.
How much material do you take to your first five-minute spot?
I’m realising “write five minutes” and “have exactly five minutes of words” probably aren’t the same thing once laughs, pauses and nerves get involved. For a first proper five-minute spot, would you rehearse something that lands comfortably under time and leave space, or prepare extra lines in case you race through it? I’d rather finish cleanly than discover my closer lives somewhere after the light.
When you finally get ten minutes, how much of your reliable five do you keep?
I’ve spent ages treating “getting to ten” as if it means finding five extra minutes. Now I’m wondering whether that’s the wrong way to think about it. If your existing five is reliable, do you keep most of it as the spine and build around it, or use the longer spot as permission to replace some of the safe stuff with material that needs more room? I don’t want ten minutes to become five proven minutes plus five minutes of homework.
Tough Crowd member feature
Find your next room
Hundreds of open mics and comedy nights, with booking instructions and real comedian reviews.
What do you do in the ten minutes before your name gets called?
I’ve got loads of advice for preparing a set, but the bit I’m bad at is the actual waiting. If I keep running lines in my head I wind myself up; if I chat to people I worry I’ll lose the opening. What do you do once you know you’re a couple of acts away — stop rehearsing completely, check the first line once, watch the room, go somewhere quiet? I’m trying to find a routine that makes me more ready rather than more nervous.
When you move from five minutes to ten, do you build out or join two bits together?
I’m trying to make the jump without ending up with ten minutes that feels like two separate fives stapled together. Is it better to take the strongest five and deliberately deepen a couple of bits, or start joining material that already works and worry about the shape later? I can see how adding more detail gives you a more coherent set, but also how it could turn a tight five into a baggy ten.
Do you keep a gig diary, or is that overkill when you're new?
I’m starting to lose track of what I actually changed between gigs. I can remember whether the night felt good or bad, but not always which version of a bit I used or what I meant to test next. Do people keep a basic gig diary from the start — date, set, what worked, one thing to change — or does that become admin you never look at again?
When do you stop calling yourself a beginner?
Not in a status way — more in terms of what you expect from yourself. I’ve done enough gigs now that saying “I’m new” can start feeling like an excuse, but I’m obviously nowhere near experienced either. Is there a point where you stopped judging a set by beginner standards and started expecting yourself to be properly consistent?
When do you stop changing your five and just let it settle?
I’m at the point where I can always find *something* to tweak before the next gig — one shorter setup, a different word, swapping two bits around. Useful at first, but I’m wondering if constant editing means I never actually learn how the same set behaves across different rooms. Do you ever deliberately freeze a five for a few gigs before changing it again?
Tough Crowd member feature
Never lose a bit again
Capture every idea the second it hits — by voice, text, or brain-dump. Tough Crowd tags and stores it for you.
How are people doing weeknight gigs without destroying the next day?
I’m trying to say yes to more stage time, but the bit nobody warned me about is getting home late on a Tuesday and then pretending to be a functioning adult at work on Wednesday. I don’t want to only gig at weekends because that cuts out loads of opportunities. For people doing comedy around a normal job, do you set a hard limit on weeknights, cluster gigs together, or just accept being knackered for a while?
When did you know your five was ready to become ten?
I’ve got a five I trust now, which is nice, but every time I try to stretch it to ten I end up adding five minutes that feels like a different act wandered on halfway through. Did you build your first ten around one idea/voice, or just keep adding the strongest bits until it eventually felt coherent?